Emma Fontanella’s Italian Shortbread Selection Box
About My Italian Shortbread Cookie Box
There’s something magical about a Christmas cookie box. But what if you could make that entire assortment from just one simple dough? This recipe does exactly that. With only five basic ingredients and a food processor, you cab create an Italian-style shortbread that’s buttery, tender, and endlessly adaptable.
Once the dough is made, you can get creative with the shapes. Cut it, shape it, roll it—turn it into logs, stars, or whatever you feel gets you in the mood for the holidays. Then finish everything with swirls or drizzles of melted chocolate, or even dip them completely. I like to use a mixture of milk and dark chocolate, so there’s something for everyone. This makes a great gift for friends, family or co-workers.
Yield: ~40–60 cookies depending on shapes
Difficulty: Easy
Time: 20 min hands-on + chilling + baking
INGREDIENTS
1¾ cups (250g) all-purpose flour
¼ tsp salt
¾ cup (80g) powdered sugar (icing sugar)
1⅓ sticks (150g) butter
2 egg yolks
2 tsp vanilla extract (pptional)
INSTRUCTIONS
Make the Dough (Food Processor Method)
In a medium-to-large food processor, add:
Flour
Salt
Powdered sugar
Pulse for a few seconds to combine.
Add the cold butter pieces. Because the butter is cold, it behaves like pie-crust butter; you’re cutting it into the dry ingredients.
Process for about 1 minute, or until the mixture resembles fine crumbs.
Add the egg yolks (and vanilla, if using).
Continue processing until the dough goes through three stages:
Shaggy crumbs
Clumping together
A rough but cohesive dough
This may take 1–2 minutes; be patient.
Bring the Dough Together
Tip the dough onto your work surface.
Use your hands to gently press and fold it together until smooth.
Because this dough has a high butter content, gluten development is minimal; you don’t need to worry about over-working it.
Roll & Shape the Cookies
Lightly flour your work surface.
Roll the dough out to ¼ inch (6 mm) thickness.
Cut using any cookie cutters you like:
Circles, stars, trees; whatever you have.
If you don’t have cutters:
Pinch off small portions of dough
Roll into a ball
Then roll into a short, slightly thick log
These “logs” are excellent once dipped in chocolate.
Place all shaped cookies onto a parchment-lined baking sheet.
Freeze Before Baking
Place the tray of cookies in the freezer for 10 minutes.
This helps them hold their shape in the oven.
Bake
Temperature: 350°F / 180°C
Time: 8–13 minutes, depending on thickness and cookie size
Doneness: Edges should be lightly golden, but overall the cookies stay pale.
Let cool completely before adding chocolate.
Melt the Chocolate
Place chopped chocolate (dark or milk) in a microwave-safe bowl.
Microwave in 30–45 second intervals, stirring each time, until mostly melted.
Stop when some small chunks remain; the residual heat will melt them.
This acts as a simple “cheat” tempering method;no thermometer required.
Chocolate-Coat or Drizzle
Place a sheet of parchment under a cooling rack.
Either:
Spoon melted chocolate over the cookies on the rack, OR
Dip the cookies directly into chocolate
Tap the tray gently to level out chocolate if spooning.
Optional:
Fill a piping bag or zip-top bag with chocolate
Snip a tiny opening
Drizzle patterns over the cookies
Let the chocolate fully set. Hardened chocolate drips on parchment can be peeled off and reused.
Storage
Store cookies in an airtight container.
They keep well at cool room temperature for 7–10 days.
Flavors improve slightly after the first day as the shortbread settles.
Assemble the Cookie Box
Arrange an assortment of shapes (plain, dipped, drizzled, and the chocolate-covered logs) in a festive tin, box, or tray.
Layer parchment between tiers if stacking.
This box makes a beautiful edible gift and stays delicious for days.
Watch the video for more tips
Hi! I’m Emma Fontanella. Here you’ll find trusted, tested recipes to satisfy your baking addiction and carb cravings. Learn more…
Tried one of my recipes? Please let me know on Instagram (@emmafontanella) or TikTok (@emma.fontanella)! Hashtag #emmafontanella
Search for another recipe…